Journal du Club des Cordeliers - Finance’s Role in Economic Ruin

NYSE - LSE
CMSC 0% 22.43 $
GSK -1.63% 37.615 $
SCS -0.1% 10.5 $
NGG -0.57% 71.82 $
RIO -1.3% 63.01 $
AZN -1.77% 72.4 $
BTI -0.68% 52.265 $
BP -0.47% 31.98 $
RYCEF -2.58% 13.16 $
RBGPF 9.33% 75 $
RELX -1.65% 52.84 $
SCU 0% 12.72 $
VOD -1.45% 11.355 $
BCC 0.4% 86.78 $
BCE -1.92% 23.97 $
CMSD -0.11% 22.824 $
JRI -0.54% 13.08 $

Finance’s Role in Economic Ruin




The finance industry, often hailed as the backbone of modern economies, has a darker side that increasingly threatens global stability. Since the 2008 financial crisis, triggered by reckless speculation in mortgage-backed securities, the sector’s unchecked growth has sown seeds of destruction. In the United States alone, the financial sector’s share of GDP rose from 2.8% in 1950 to 8.4% by 2020, yet it produced no tangible goods, instead profiting from debt and risk. Critics argue this shift diverts capital from productive industries like manufacturing—down from 27% to 11% of US GDP over the same period to speculative bubbles.

The 2023 collapse of Silicon Valley Bank, fuelled by over-leveraged bets on tech stocks, cost $20 billion in bailouts and sparked a domino effect across European markets. In the UK, the 2022 mini-budget crisis, exacerbated by hedge fund short-selling of gilts, pushed borrowing costs to record highs. Economist Ann Pettifor warns, “Finance thrives on instability it creates”. With global debt at $305 trillion—three times world GDP—experts fear the industry’s pursuit of profit through complex derivatives and high-frequency trading could precipitate another crash. Is finance an engine of growth or a wrecking ball?